Substack vs Mailchimp (2026)

Zero-cost newsletter platform with paid subscriptions vs the full email marketing suite — updated April 2026.

Quick Verdict: Substack wins 7-5 for writers and independent journalists. It's completely free (takes 10% of paid subs), has built-in discoverability, and zero technical setup. Mailchimp wins for businesses that need advanced email automation, segmentation, and full platform ownership.

Best for Writers

Substack

Free newsletter platform with built-in paid subscriptions

⭐ 4.5/5

Pros

Completely free (10% of paid revenue only)
Built-in paid subscription tiers
Substack discovery network
Web publication and archives
Podcast hosting included

Cons

10% fee on paid subscriptions is high at scale
Limited customization vs Mailchimp
No advanced automation or segmentation

Free (10% of paid subscription revenue)

Start on Substack Free →

Best for Business Email

Mailchimp

Full email marketing platform with automation

⭐ 4.3/5

Pros

Free plan for 500 contacts
Advanced automation workflows
Segmentation and personalization
300+ integrations
Full ownership of your audience

Cons

No built-in paid subscriptions
No platform discoverability
Monthly cost grows with list size

Free (500 contacts) or from $13/mo

Try Mailchimp Free →

Side-by-Side Comparison

Category	Substack	Mailchimp
Monthly Cost	Free (10% paid subs)	Free or $13+/mo
Paid Subscriptions	✅ Built-in	❌
Discoverability	✅ Network	❌
Web Publication	✅	Basic
Podcast Hosting	✅	❌
Automation	Limited	✅ Advanced
Segmentation	Basic	✅ Advanced
A/B Testing	❌	✅
Integrations	Limited	300+
Data Ownership	Export available	✅ Full
Custom Domain	✅	✅
Score	7/10	5/10

Which do you use?

Substack

Mailchimp

Who Should Choose Each Tool

Choose Substack if you…

Are a writer or journalist starting a newsletter
Want zero upfront cost to get started
Plan to monetize through paid subscriptions
Want Substack's built-in discovery network

Choose Mailchimp if you…

Run a business with complex email automation
Need advanced segmentation and personalization
Want full ownership without platform fees
Require integrations with your business stack

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Substack really free?

Yes. Substack is free to use with no monthly fees. They take a 10% cut of paid subscription revenue. For free newsletters with no paid tiers, Substack costs nothing.

Should I use Substack or Mailchimp for my newsletter?

Use Substack if you are a writer wanting the simplest possible setup with built-in paid subscriptions and audience discovery. Use Mailchimp if you need advanced email automation, segmentation, or want to own your platform fully.

Can you move from Substack to Mailchimp?

Yes. Substack allows you to export your subscriber list as a CSV, which you can import into Mailchimp. The process is straightforward but you lose the Substack web publication and discovery features.

Get our free SaaS Buyer's Guide (PDF)

Save hours of research. We cover pricing traps, hidden fees, and how to negotiate better deals.

Join 0 SaaS buyers. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Methodology: Scores are based on feature depth, pricing value, user reviews from G2 and Capterra, and hands-on testing. Updated April 2026.

Ready to share your writing with the world?

Start on Substack Free →Try Mailchimp Free →

Share:𝕏 in f r/

Last updated: April 10, 2026